You Started It, Pal.
#32 posted by Breezeep_ on 2017/06/17 04:54:52
Look, we get it. You don't like knave. Would you kindly stop posting for a while and stop this thread from going further off the tracks?
That's Just The Thing,
#33 posted by Mugwump on 2017/06/17 05:17:16
I didn't start anything! I only made an inoffensive comment and then got bashed for it for no valid reason. After that I only defended myself. I'm not the aggressor here, don't pick the wrong target. May I point that I did want to end this 3 posts ago? The "peace out" bit. But I'll never be one to bow to attackers, so if they keep at it I keep defending myself. You want it to stop, ask the perpetrator.
Shut The Fuck Up Already...
#34 posted by khreathor on 2017/06/17 05:19:36
Meanwhile... Back On Topic
...but if we are bound to sticking with engines using Protocol 666 (which allow mostly bigger limits anyway) then why are we trying to stick to the original BSP? Honest question to try and understand the reasoning and more of the tech side of this.
#36 posted by khreathor on 2017/06/17 05:45:29
Extended limits let you do a lot of brushwork anyway, so there is no point of using BSP2, until you reach the first limit.
Internet Diva/Perpetrator
#37 posted by skacky on 2017/06/17 05:46:47
Do you even hear yourself? The reason people around here don't like you much is because you're a passive-aggressive jerk and with your year-old account and your 1,000+ posts (most of them about yourself in some capacity, hence the narcissist bit) you have contributed nothing of value so far for the community and are actively creating dissent whether you realize it or not. You've been told repeatedly by various people that you're attitude is frankly bothersome. I've been quiet but I've honestly had enough. You reappear and the first thing you do is complain about a lack of 2017 releases since Retro Jam 6 and then whine about this jam's theme. So please, please excuse me if I take your unwanted bitching about the theme the wrong way, especially since you evidently aren't even planning on doing anything for this jam in the first place. Sure, I didn't ask your directly whether you were entering. I did ask you indirectly though.
You should maybe think once or twice before you post something in the future, actually contribute something valuable or change your attitude altogether. That first post of yours was uncalled for. You have the right to have an opinion; everyone does, but we certainly didn't need to hear it.
What do you think this is? This is a tribute jam. The maps in this jam are going to be similar to what Kell did. There is nothing wrong with that and people are excited for this for the simple reason that Contract Revoked is a milestone and to this day remains one of the finest Quake releases, no matter how stale you think it has become (it hasn't). Please do enter and show us what you can do with Knave and I bet people will love it if you manage to pull something unseen off. I'm being 100% sincere here.
Anyway, off to bed.
#38 posted by negke on 2017/06/17 09:07:42
I was super-excited for this jam, but then I saw skacky's hatemongering rant and now Knave & Quoth are dead to me forever...
Well
#39 posted by Tronyn on 2017/06/17 09:22:32
The only way to heal the universe is obviously a negke knave map. I surely can't be the only one who wants to see this; a cyclical, infinite dark world where even the elevators respawn.
Skacky, Please,
#40 posted by Mugwump on 2017/06/17 10:12:22
this has been requested by several people already, including me: if you insist on continuing this crap, do so in the GA thread and leave this one to on-topic stuff, dammit! Like this for instance:
I've just played the map that OTP linked to in post #28 and that's exactly what I was talking about: a much less common use of the knave set. That's only one example of the kind of stuff I'm looking forward to see and I suggest that entrants check this map if they haven't yet. Who said tributes can't take creative liberties? At any rate, they should. I haven't had a reason to say this very often yet, but here it is well deserved: thanks to OTP for sharing this (and also to the author for making it in the first place, of course)!
Well
#41 posted by PuLSaR on 2017/06/17 15:01:37
I think that map jams always show how different one theme can turn out in every mapper's way. That's was what impresses me in any map jam every time. Therefore I think it's too early to complain about the similarity of Knave maps (I don't think it is).
Look at Nastrond, apsp3, hrimfaxi's knave maps and many others. They can be outdoors map, indoor maps, they may be located in giant caves. So it's all up to the author's vision of his map. I think there were even coagula knave maps.
So it's a great opportunity to show how different knave maps can be. So go map instead of complaining.
The idea of sticking to bsp format is for aiming for not that large maps so one can finish it to the deadline (unless you are Tronyn).
About WAD
#42 posted by xlarve on 2017/06/17 16:52:38
Original quake textures is valid?
I'd Suggest To Use Knave.wad Only
#43 posted by PuLSaR on 2017/06/17 17:03:53
You can use some id.wad textures like lava or trims as long as knave is dominating texture set in your map
Def Or Ent
#44 posted by anonymous user on 2017/06/17 17:04:00
Has anyone made a def file for quoth2? No luck in my search
#45 posted by Mugwump on 2017/06/17 17:16:05
(unless you are Tronyn)
*chuckles*
I think that map jams always show how different one theme can turn out in every mapper's way.
Agreed. RJ6 in particular proved that quite brilliantly.
it's too early to complain
Does anyone here really believe that I was complaining in advance about the outcome of this jam?! That would be pretty rich! I was of course talking about the knave maps I have already played, as a reminder to keep it personal rather than too faithful to the classic knave style as found in maps like Red777 or Conference of the Shamblers. I browsed the wad this morning and this set has so much potential that it's a bit saddening to see it used predominantly (I didn't say exclusively, mind you) along the lines set by these classics. Imagination is the one and only key to ever hope to rival such masterpieces.
As for Yours Truly mapping for a jam, I doubt it will happen anytime soon: first, I still feel far from confident enough in my mapping skills to undertake something with such a short deadline, plus I have stressed in my comeback post that I won't have much time to map at all in the foreseeable future. I need to find a job and that doesn't leave much room for such a time-consuming endeavor. I may have pulled something off for the QUMP project but the ship has sailed and it's much too late now.
One final note: thank you PuLSaR for not partaking in the haters' bandwagon! It is so much more pleasant when my interlocutor is capable of having a respectful, grown-up conversation...
Cheers!
#44
#46 posted by muk on 2017/06/17 17:37:41
#47 posted by anonymous user on 2017/06/17 17:43:45
more fgd
Was looking for something compatible with radiant =p
Love Knave!
#48 posted by Giftmacher on 2017/06/17 20:21:18
I'll try and speedmap / make something small, limited time during weekends
#49 posted by muk on 2017/06/18 04:52:09
awwww i just noticed my book textures are in the jam wad.
<3<3<3
makes me feel all tingly inside, thanks pulsar!
#50 posted by Zwiffle on 2017/06/19 04:12:17
Wish I could, knave has a special place in my heart, just don't have the time :( Look forward to seeing the results, though!
Just Out Of Curiosity...
#51 posted by Mugwump on 2017/06/19 05:35:46
Why four 9's in the jam title?
Reference
#52 posted by mjb on 2017/06/19 14:26:24
Mugwump Pls
#53 posted by allcaps on 2017/06/19 17:10:27
We get it you're unhappy you can stop
Huh, Wut???
#54 posted by Mugwump on 2017/06/19 17:31:16
First, your post shows that you totally don't get what I was saying earlier, and second, I'd be curious as to what unhappy vibe you could possibly infer from my genuine question.
Zwiffle
#55 posted by PuLSaR on 2017/06/19 17:37:12
Wish I could, knave has a special place in my heart, just don't have the time :( Look forward to seeing the results, though!
You have at least 3 weekend. You can make a very small map for it.
Finally Trying Again
#56 posted by ShoTro on 2017/06/19 17:42:00
I might actually have time for this mapjam. I have an unorthodox idea I wanted to try with Quoth for a while. I should be able to knock out a small map for this jam.
|