By requiring specific engines you reduce the "audience" of your map significantly and piss off quite a few people. I wouldn't recommend it. 

By requiring specific engines you reduce the "audience" of your map significantly

- I guess those still playing this game would know how to handle that (it's not like we're talking about a superadvanced engine that requires tons of extra downloads)

- if players can't be arsed to rtfm and follow a simple link - their loss 

I guess those still playing this game would know how to handle that
If you want to limit your audience to people who know that stuff then fine. But take a look around (the quakeone.com forum attracts a lot of clueless newbies for example) and you will see that there are quite a few "invisible" people that will struggle. Hell, many people use glquake and just don't care about a map that does not run in it.

if players can't be arsed to rtfm and follow a simple link - their loss
If that is the mapper's attitude it's ok. I'm just saying. 

People should finally wise up and realize that in order to keep this game alive after 12 years, these kinds of development have to be accepted.
Even the dumbest newbie should be able to get a map to run if the readme explains it properly (optimally also supplying links to the required engines and resources).

If they follow this ridiculous attitude of strictly denying to use anything but their engine of choice or even not wanting to "clutter their Quake dir", then it's indeed their problem.

I could imagine the future of Quake mapping to rely more strongly on new engine features, at least once DP has finally become properly playable. The Doom community demonstrates this perfectly. There are so many maps using ZDoom features and nobody complains about the need to use it. 

But for that to happen engines must be more polished and working nicely. I mean, what engines are "it"?
The current Fitzquake crashes on those maps.
aguirRe's engine has no full- nor overbrights.
Darkplaces is Darkplaces.

Just look at how awesome ZDoom is. It is no surprise it is being used. Just like ezQuake.

And yes, sure it is their problem. It is totally the decision of the mapper to in- or exclude them (I am saying that without any "weight"). I just wanted to raise awareness of "them" 

.. RTFM...

AFAIK, there's always a txt file in which you'll find all the necesary informations about how to play properly a map... even about engine download link if necessary... so you do not exclude people, you are just warning them about the mandatory use of specifics... though... 

<rj> the texture thing isn't ready yet. I'm only trying to see how far I can go with adding brushes. But your concern is noticed, thanks.

<jpl> It isn't the size but the lightmap thing. I just went to the moment adding a brush would leave me with the max lightmap default. So the map is alright but a bit plain, which I can't avoid by adding ornements.
And I have already scaled up all outside and unused brushes. 

If they follow this ridiculous attitude of strictly denying to use anything but their engine of choice

My engine of choice is exactly that - my engine of choice. I choose to use it because I like it, and for various reasons I actively dislike all other alternatives I've tried.

If there is a map that doesn't run in my engine of choice then in all likelihood I'm not going to be motivated to go out of my way to play it.

Some of you guys seem to be missing the key point here. I understand or can learn how to download and configure the various engines available, sure. But why the fuck should I? I don't enjoy playing in most of the asstacular engines available, and unless the map is the next coming of christ then it's simply not worth it for me.

Naturally if the mapper chooses to release a map that requires a particular engine or mod, good luck to him! Obviously that's the mapper's choice, but you do need to understand that this will limit your audience to some extent. If you don't care, fine... great. If you do care, then ensure compatibility with standard engines. 

Warp was this - you couldn't play it in anything but it's own engines.

I never made it for anyone else, really. It was fun to make it. A labour of love. That some people enjoyed playing it was nice to hear.

If it got missed by, let's say, 90% of the Q1 players because it had it's own specific engines then I'm not going to cry.

We're talking about a 12 year old game - having anyone interested in your map is a bonus. 

I love us all!!! (and AgiurRe)

Someone should port AGLQuake to Mac/OSX, just to prevent lengthy flame wars! Willem?

(This is a genuine suggestion, we all know where we stand on this issue, I'm not trying to instigate another riot...) 

Sleepwalkr is a better choice for that kind of a job. I'm just a tools schlub. 

I'm creating a racing map for Quake Wars. There will be 2 versions, one for the wheels of war mod and a stand alone level. Its nearly finished so hopefully beta it soon.

http://bp1.blogger.com/_sR6bZBrp_nY/SHPwUEcggeI/AAAAAAAAAGA/drwhxoi62UU/s1600-h/shot00025+copy.jpg

http://bp2.blogger.com/_sR6bZBrp_nY/SG9il2o6FmI/AAAAAAAAAFA/ooeWPbxbJNY/s1600-h/Untitled-2.jpg

more pics on my blog.
http://quakewarsmapping.blogspot.com/ 

the 2nd shot reminds me of a part from san andreas! :)

looks great though. it looks like a cool place to drive in :) 

http://jago.pp.fi/images/UED3.jpg 

I like it! Looks like you're making some good progress with the editor Jago :) Stick with it! 

http://daz.quaddicted.com/

Perhaps a qexpo release if I pull my finger out :) 

(drool) 

some of those unfinished maps look really good. Finish them off! 

base are belong to DaZ 

I am calling your bluff - those are the only rooms you've built! Prove me wrong. 

cool Daz you invested already to much time on it _;) please finish it!!! 

Lun will back my up, I hit max visleafs when I compiled the other day, so either those rooms are way overdetailed or there is more :) 

you sealed it and the error didn't go away? 

Glad to see you're investing more time. Still looks rad. 

neg|ke or anyone need more maya textures!!! any idear?

i�m using hexen2 and rogue wads