#3056
#3057 posted by muk on 2017/11/13 22:34:22
Its not too much work. They already did it in the admod version of Quakespasm released with Sepulcher.
@mukor
#3058 posted by iriyap on 2017/11/13 23:00:31
Indeed, I'm aware. And that particular version causes bugs like this:
admod:
https://i.imgur.com/hS07r5x.jpg
vanilla QS:
https://i.imgur.com/0QR3BCL.jpg
@iriyap
I'd take that minor bug over not having the menu. I'm for adding it to QS. I use a launcher but I think we should all want Quake to be easier to use for newbs.
@dumptruck_ds
#3060 posted by iriyap on 2017/11/13 23:44:28
The main menu is a single image, not a font. To add a new option, you have to replace the whole thing. There is no way to add extra options without sacrificing compatibility with mods that use custom main menu graphics (e.g. Rubicon series, Malice, Shrak, X-Men, many other TCs, etc). This is the reason why very few source ports ever touch it (JoeQuake only?).
Not to mention that we already have so many options for launching mods, like using shortcuts, .bat files, external launchers and also console commands. I'm sure even the most casual of the players can figure out how to use a launcher. It's just a program with a bunch of dropdown menus where you choose your engine, mod folder and what map to launch, if any.
If we wanted to accommodate newbies so much, we could also start adding regenerating health and such. I'd rather QS retains its full vanilla compatibility, it's the main reason the engine is the number one choice for Quake in numerous retro gaming communities.
If we wanted to accommodate newbies so much, we could also start adding regenerating health and such.
Arcane Dimensions, arguably the best mod in years, has respawning ammo and health. So there's that.
Back on topic, there are very few TCs compared to straight up mods. I still think adding a mod menu would be more beneficial than not. And I'm sure there's a way to make it work with TC's anyway.
#3062 posted by muk on 2017/11/14 03:04:00
"If we wanted to accommodate newbies so much, we could also start adding regenerating health and such."
That has absolutely nothing with the subject at hand but ok.
Having the Mods option was more about getting more people to play Quake that arent comfortable with setting up folders. The same crowd of people that Quake Injector is made for.
But yeah that kind of sucks it breaks things. I need to wake up more before i start func_ing.
#3063 posted by iriyap on 2017/11/14 03:11:46
Yeah, I might have gone a bit off tangent with that comment, got carried a way a bit, didn't mean to preach.
Point is, yeah, it breaks things. In theory, you could break up the original image and add another image just with the "Mods" part, but the font will be clashing with the TCs. Maybe add this new menu under the options screen? This would work, that one is all text.
Still, I'd rather this was external, maybe via some official QS launcher or such, if you want everything in one package.
#3064 posted by ericw on 2017/11/14 04:10:38
I was also thinking it could be a menu item in the "options" menu - that would avoid issues with custom graphics. The only downside is it's one more thing in the "options" screen which has a tendency to keep growing.
New Menus
#3065 posted by Spike on 2017/11/14 04:41:55
stuff like this is why I gave FTE the ability to query a file's depth.
eg if the menu artwork is in id1 then replace it with a new menu with a mods option etc. otherwise a mod has replaced it and the vanilla layout+filename should be used. it gives the best of both worlds.
More Skin Issues
#3066 posted by iriyap on 2017/11/14 05:20:41
Found another broken skin in Shrak:
QuakeSpasm r1532:
https://i.imgur.com/AuaZ5kI.jpg
Mark V:
https://i.imgur.com/BVq71Pe.jpg
It's a Pentagram replacement, just load dm3 to see it.
WinQuake and DarkPlaces display it properly as well, but it's black in QuakeSpasm, DirectQ and FitzQuake 0.85.
@Spike
#3067 posted by iriyap on 2017/11/14 05:28:56
Don't really want to be the bad guy on this idea, but one last point, hear me out. Consider this, the "mods" option is mostly for the newbies sake, right? So they use it to load some mod which happens to have custom main menu graphics, and bam, the option is suddenly gone. Cue all the false bug reporting and complaining. Not to mention that the lack of consistency is not good UX.
Shrak Skin Issue
#3068 posted by ericw on 2017/11/14 06:41:19
Thanks for the report. It's caused by Mod_FloodFillSkin (commenting that out in Mod_LoadAllSkins fixes it).. I think the flood fill breaks on solid color skins. Might wait until after this release to investigate how MarkV fixed it.
#3069 posted by metlslime on 2017/11/14 07:34:13
Just put mods and maps in the "new game" menu
Also, Re: #3049
#3070 posted by metlslime on 2017/11/14 08:35:09
Here's an example of a zoom script that is agnostic to your current sensitivity cvar. This modifies m_pitch and m_yaw instead of sensitivity.
alias +zoom "fov 105; wait; fov 72; wait; fov 53; wait; fov 34; wait; fov 15; m_yaw 0.004; m_pitch -0.004"
alias -zoom "fov 15; wait; fov 34; wait; fov 53; wait; fov 72; wait; fov 105; m_yaw 0.022; m_pitch -0.022"
Of course it does assume a specific fov. Use iriyap's suggestion and use inc command to make it relative to any starting fov value. (though it could break if it tries to go below the min value.)
@ericw
#3071 posted by iriyap on 2017/11/14 13:51:45
Just noticed that the 3D crosshair for the RL in Shrak is also solid color and also affected by this bug.
32 Bpp
#3072 posted by maiden on 2017/11/14 23:46:04
Not sure if posting in the right thread, but I'm having trouble running QS in 32-bit colour. Highest available setting is my native resolution (1600x900) and 24 bpp. Any hints on how to troubleshoot?
#3073 posted by maiden on 2017/11/15 00:38:16
The version is 0.92.2-admod-win32 from sock's Arcane Dimensions page. QuakeSpasm 0.92.1-win64 runs 32-bit colour fine.
It's Fine
#3074 posted by ericw on 2017/11/15 01:07:31
24 and 32 are pretty much different names for the same thing (they're both 8 bits per channel). It's probably just a naming difference between SDL2 and SDL1.2 .
#3075 posted by maiden on 2017/11/15 03:18:07
OK thanks.
@ericw
There seems to be a gamma shift (lower, brighter) when I switch refresh rate to match my desktop refresh rate. If you cannot reproduce, I can make a video after work tonight. Or is this expected?
Dumptruck
#3077 posted by ericw on 2017/11/15 22:15:07
Hm, that's not good. I'll see if I can reproduce it.
@dumptruck_ds
#3078 posted by ericw on 2017/11/16 02:04:25
Can't reproduce on my system (latest windows 10, nvidia 650); tried 800x600@60 and 800x600@75 hz.
I can't think of an explanation, but a couple questions: do the QS brightness/contrast sliders work in both video modes? If you still get a gamma shift with both "gamma" and "contrast" cvars set to 1, it's likely something outside of QS causing the gamma difference.
Is it possible there's a different gamma setting for that video mode in your graphics driver control panel? I'm not sure if that is a feature, just guessing here.
Does it happen in any other game?
@ericw
I am still at work but will do some more work on this tonight. I doubt it's an external nvidia thing. I switch refresh rates a lot with QS and QS Admod etc. as I am working on the Xmas jam at the moment. I map and test at 72hz and then play for fun at 144. Will report back in a few hours.
I will check the sliders in both modes. And other games.
@ericw
Tested this. Happened again. But here is the weird thing: I took screenshots and they match. However, I am def noticing an increase in overall brightness.
Will keep exploring this but did not happen with .92x and Admod versions. Very strange. The brightness isn't horrible just noticeable. Here's a PDf with the screens for reference - you will not see any diff between them but thought I'd include for further discussion.
https://adobe.ly/2AQ2JDI
|