|
Posted by Baker on 2010/08/20 23:27:49 |
This engine needs its own thread.
Feedback: I like the OS X version, but I have to start it from the terminal for it to work and can't just double-click it like a traditional OS X app. I'm sure you guys already know this, either way great engine.
http://quakespasm.sourceforge.net/ |
|
|
@Spirit
#1001 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 16:28:46
>I would offer to write a Bash script to do this if you are on Linux? >Otherwise maybe >https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/random_map.php is enough for >ideas?
I'm on OS X.
And no, using a web site to select a random map isn't usefull. I would like to randomly select a map from my personnal collection, from WITHIN the game (QS).
I think this command would be a great addition to the game, especially if you do have lots of maps in our id1/maps folder. And since I can't put the game to the background (a Quake3 feature that I was asking for Quake1), I can't consult the internet while QS is running.
I don't see how that randmap command would "not fit" QS's philosophy.
Barnak
For umpteenth time: hit alt enter to switch to windowed mode, then go to the menu to unfreeze the mouse. Is that really so hard?
@SleepwalkR
#1003 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 16:54:50
This is a pain in the ass just to select some random map.
Is it really so hard to add a randmap command ?
#1004 posted by Spirit on 2014/08/16 17:19:13
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feature_creep
It probably is not hard to add but it would be hard to do well. What about deathmatch maps, what about bsp files that are not maps, what about maps that are later part of an episode? That would be hard.
You are just one user and would probably be the only one who used this feature.
Does QS support loading a map (in a running instance) by doubleclicking it?
@Spirit
#1005 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 17:30:45
Double-clicking a .bsp file to launch QS and play that map would be great too, I suppose. It's currently not working on OS X. And double-clicking a bsp file which isn't a map wouldn't be that great neither, I guess.
Do you put non-map bsp files into your id1/maps folder ?
And even if we have such maps in id1/maps, using the randmap command would simply give an error message, as if you tried to open it using the standard map command. The user then simply has to use the randmap again to select another random map.
I don't think that non-maps bsp file would cause that much troubles.
Do you put non-map bsp files into your id1/maps folder ?
Ammo boxes, health boxes, exploding boxes are all bsp files.
"randmap" As An Alternative To "map"
#1007 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 17:36:39
I see the "randmap" command as simply an alternative to the usual "map" command, without a mapname argument.
Even if it selects a deathmatch map, so what ? I would use "randmap" again, until I get some playable map.
This would be so much easier to start a random game, especially with a bind to a keyboard shortcut.
#1008 posted by R00k on 2014/08/16 17:53:10
[quote]
what about my suggestion of a new console command to load a random map, so the player don't know in advance which map will be loaded.
[/quote]
In Qrack I added such a thing, though, use the existing changelevel command. So in effect if the user just types
]changelevel
without a map specified it loads a random map from the gamedir.
I'm sure it would be trivial to port.
#1009 posted by anonymous user on 2014/08/16 17:59:42
sorry to double post, Lightning Hunter requested this feature to me a few years back. His use was for FrikBots. He had all his DEATHMATCH maps and waypoint files in the frikbot folder.
I agree with Spirit, for single-player it might seem a bit disjointed.
R00k, My Love !
#1010 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 18:00:26
Haa ! I knew it !
Please, port this to QS !
Barnak
#1011 posted by spy on 2014/08/16 18:44:52
why would you wanna the randmap command???
it is a most idiotic request i've ever heard
#1012 posted by Spirit on 2014/08/16 18:51:24
To play a random map.
@spy
#1013 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 18:52:47
It is certainly NOT an idiotic request. It actually says a lot about your own way of playing Quake !
As I already said several times, I have hundreds of custom maps in my id1/maps folder. Most of the times, when I launch QS, I simply don't know which maps I'm gonna play. And there's no way I can know in advance what a map is looking like, just by looking at its name in the map list.
So I start by launching a random map from the list. It's a pain in the ass to look up the whole list (hundreds of fucking weird names!), and type it in the console, then repeat the process again after I played the map.
The randmap command would ease that A LOT !
Is that so hard to understand !? WTF !
#1014 posted by Spirit on 2014/08/16 18:59:39
You do know the Quake Injector, right? It's what I use when I get a random craving. Just scroll randomly and click.
Barnak
#1015 posted by Cocerello on 2014/08/16 19:04:39
Close your eyes, get your finger out, and point to your screen at random with the window with the maps open. Or input the ''maps'' command and press page down a random amount of secs.
Well, jokes aside, that feature isn't something that would make your life so easy that you need it for sure, judging by the amount of posts you are writing. It would save you just a little work.
The second point is that there is only a few people that would use it. Everyone has their own way of playing the maps. I for example delete them after playing.
Third what was already said before, it has conflicts with .bsp files in id1\maps\ that aren't maps.
Spirit
#1016 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 19:08:11
Apparently, Quake Injector don't work very well on OS X.
And I would **hate** to use an extra program just to launch a random map. It would be much easier to launch a random map directly from within QS.
Geez, I don't need all the Quake Injector functionalities built in QS, just a random map loading as an alternative to the usual map command, that's all.
Since nobody here appears to understand what I'm asking, I'll shut my mouth and wont participate anymore to this forum.
Maybe
#1017 posted by ijed on 2014/08/16 19:48:43
You'd have better luck if you'd asked politely instead of petulantly demanding that others spend their hobby time, which they use for fun, to implement a feature for you.
And here's a really wacky idea:
Some time ago I wanted to make custom enemies for quake. So I opened up the qc and learned how to script it. Saying "I don't know how" is not an excuse - everyone starts like that.
@ijed
#1018 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 19:56:48
About your wacky idea :
So do you think it's possible to make some bsp file that would launch a random map from a list ?
I may be tempted in trying to do it myself, if it's possible to define such a random map process.
No Idea
#1019 posted by ijed on 2014/08/16 20:38:45
How the feature could be made. There will be multiple solutions.
The one that comes to mind, that I know how to do, is write a simple qc randomizer and write a list of maps into it. Then launch it from a console command.
You'd need to update it and recompile to add new maps, but that's trivial.
Check out www.inside3d.com - it has lots of tutorials, maybe you can adapt one.
To compile the qc I recommend fteqcc compiler, though I don't have the website to hand.
I would actually write the qc you need for you (it's pretty easy) but I have to limit my time at the computer and prefer time I do spend there to used working on my current project.
Huh
Barnak, everyone understands what you're asking. They got it the first time. Everyone's just like, nope
@ijed
#1021 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 21:03:52
Thanks for the info.
Do you have a code file that could help me start the project ?
And what app to compile quake code on OS X ?
I'm in total blackness void here.
Inside3D
#1022 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 21:18:36
Should I start a new thread for this ?
I've found this code, but I don't know what to do with it :
http://www.inside3d.com/showtutorial.php?id=158
@Barnak
#1023 posted by Spike on 2014/08/16 21:32:36
firstly:
using a mod to select a random map is kinda silly.
the reason for this is two-fold, a) you need to load the mod somehow (gamedir command? means it can't work with (other) mods). b) you need to load a map before you can run any qc.
so really you're not that better off than using an external tool to pick maps.
I doubt QuakeSpasm supports DP_QC_FS_SEARCH, and I've no idea if it supports FRIK_FILE. Hardcoding a maplist is easy enough (yay arrays), but not for a user who wants everything to be straightforward.
secondly:
official fteqcc (svn) builds can be downloaded from here: http://triptohell.info/moodles/fteqcc/
latest and breakiest and all that.
I can't support mac. all the things on cross compiling *to* mac all seem to say 'you will need: 1 mac', which completely defeats the point of cross compiling.
if anyone wants to compile one for me, give me a link and I can link to your site as you desire, but I can't maintain it myself.
@Spike
#1024 posted by Barnak on 2014/08/16 23:58:40
Hmmm, sorry to be a shit fly, but I really didn't understood an iota of what you have written.
And apparently, it's a pain in the arse to compile QC codes on OS X. The old Quake tools on OS 9 aren't supported anymore.
(from http://forums.inside3d.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=4821 and other places)
Spike
I know that szo has somehow set up a cross compilation toolchain for QuakeSpasm. He can do Mac builds on Linux, but I have no idea how he did it.
|
|
You must be logged in to post in this thread.
|
Website copyright © 2002-2024 John Fitzgibbons. All posts are copyright their respective authors.
|
|