Windows are fine, that sort of unnatural spilling I think is fine in Quake 

That literally looks like this http://multiplayerblog.mtv.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/diablo-fan-06.jpg 

 

is that a remake of e2m1? (I got that impression, or at least an e2-ish impression, from the moat/drawbridge type setup).
Looks amazing. Extremely atmospheric.

ps, I always light windows like that. if it's inside the light must be coming from outside, if it's outside the light must be coming from inside, heh. 

I guess what hits me wrong there is not necessarily that it's physically inaccurate but more that it makes it plainly obvious that there's a spherical light source sitting in front of the window. I dunno ... I'll shut up. :) 

I agree with willem, FWIW

The current technique would probably be fine if the light was more subtle. Currently it's bright enough that it has my brain looking for a source. Dimmer and I might accept it as general ambient lighting bounced from somwhere else. 

nope i like the blue sky over that dull grey. adds contrasting colour and is unique. 

I think it's the fact that the sky is the only thing in the scene with that color. When compositing a scene you need to repeat the main hues in several locations in a scene or it might look off. Ditto for the windows actually. It doesn't need to be as bright or saturated either, just repeating a certain set of hues already helps a lot. I tried to tone it down to bring it more in line with the rest of the scene, but ideally there should be other things in the set that share the color palette. 

https://www.dropbox.com/s/h13yssu9o5hq6wb/telefragged_001.png

https://www.dropbox.com/s/l2h6b9okm8zq8d8/telefragged_002.png

Yeah, dropbox. Sorry I'm in a hurry. 

http://i.imgur.com/cS23Qyw.png

http://i.imgur.com/ffZUnLF.png 

Shot 1 Shot 2

wip.. 

Looks like a lot of rubicon stuff in the works. :) 

be sure, there is. 

That last shot owns! 

 

or not?

Screenshot 

But it's kind of flat, and in more way than one. The lighting could be a bit more dramatic, surely, and perhaps sink the middle of the floor, a bit? 

I have been wondering how much detail you can pack in to a map before things start to break. I got to this point when I started seeing wandering vertices and degradation.

http://www.quaketastic.com/files/screen_shots/5the1m1.jpg 

How about a spotlight above the pentagram so it casts it's shadow on the floor?

5th, nice stuff, but it's a bit bright - some shadows would help. 

That's an editor shot ijed. 

And trenchbroom needs a lighting preview!

Also, I'll post some proper shots of mine (with proper links as well) soon. 

I feel like the gate and teleporter are too small for the scale of that room. Perhaps just making the gate larger would do it.

Otherwise, yeah it's cheesy, but such is Quake amirite 

Yeah, the lighting in that room needs work, that's why I'm looking at it. The floor could be less flat also, don't know if my marksurfaces can handle that though.

How about a spotlight above the pentagram</>

There already is one, but it's turned off in that shot.

the gate and teleporter are too small

I'm pretty sure it just looks that way because of the angle you are seeing it at and partly because I kicked the fov up to 100 just for that shot. The actual distance between the gate and the teleporter is over 800 units. Both the gate and the teleporter are pretty large, 192x192 I think. 

mfx: i love the super tall hallway in the right side of your second shot. more of that please! 

I decided to register since i'm becoming interested with this community. also, screenies:
http://i.imgur.com/aZWtINM.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/N9CJjl4.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/xpt88vy.jpg