There's a reason I still play Quake and have probably played more hours in that than other FPSes added together. Bout other FPSes can still be fun, and given the dearth of other good visceral / fantastical FPSes in recent years, it's worth discussing the few around. 

I don't think anyone hated it. I really disliked how quickly the second area was over, the last level felt unfinished. 

 

They did some Java mobile games. Those take the cake. 

There's some who'd say that Doom 3 is their worst game. I might be bold enough to say that Doom 2 is only good because of the SSG and the new enemies, but the level design generally stank.

As for the Java games, I really enjoyed their NDS updated version of Orcs and Elves. 

Excepting original Dooms as I don't really know those, add those around the top 2/3 as required...

Quake
Quake 2
Doom 4
Rage 2 / Doom 3
Rage
Quake 4
.
.
.
Quake Live
.
.
.
...long gap...
.
.
.
Q3A / Quake Chumps

HTH. 

How is Q3A way worse than Q4? That one isn't even by idSoft BTW. 

Q3A isn't even a game BTW. It's an engine test. The MP-only bullshit is also objectively terrible multiplayer mechanics / gamefeel too. 

you realise that deep down, they all fucking suck.

The only one that doesn't suck is the best bits of the 23 years of community-made content for quake 1. 

Q1 fucking owns. 

RAGE 2: TerrorMania is out now!

trailer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ernp46e-dUY

In the second expansion you’ll explore the twisted and cursed alternate reality of the wasteland, the Deadlands. Reverse the curse before the skeletal forces of darkness can break free and take over the land of the living. Arm yourself with a brand-new weapon – a powerful sword that’s also the key to unlocking the gates between realities – and face off against a legion of skeletal enemies.

Available through the in-game store!

RAGE 2: TerrorMania Introduces:

-New Weapon: Sword of Transitus – An ancient relic of unspeakable power.

-New Location: The Deadlands – Explore an alternate reality version of the wasteland. Once you complete the DLC story, you’ll be able to return to each location in the Deadlands and experience them again.

-New Enemy: Army of the Dead – Face off against the undead versions of familiar factions like the Goon Squad, Immortal Shrouded, River Hogs and Abadon Muties.