Licenses
#29452 posted by Mugwump on 2017/07/30 05:09:23
Can music made using a GPL sample be released under CC? I also used several CC samples in this track and they require that I use the same license, so I was wondering about possible licensing conflicts.
Mugwump
#29453 posted by mankrip on 2017/07/30 08:20:42
Creative Commons is not one license; it's a set of several licenses with significantly different restrictions and liberties between them.
I tend to avoid CC-licensed content like the plague because of this; it's not rare for authors to not understand the differences between CC0, CC1, CC2, etc, before licensing their work under one of them. It may be possible that they think it's like GPL v2, v3, etc, where the number simply denotes an update.
Some CC licenses are compatible with the GPL, some are not. IMO, it's not worth the trouble, but you can analyze each license of each sample to see if any of them uses a GPL-conflicting CC license.
#29454 posted by Mugwump on 2017/07/30 08:52:17
Well, the CC-licensed samples are CC0 (I misspoke when I said they required that my work used the same license, it's another track of mine which does). The GPL sample is from Tenshihan's GPL Soundbank, which I think was released in 2003, so it's likely to be GPLv1 but I'm not sure. My work is intended to be released under CC-BY-SA 4.0.
I've read on the CC wiki that this CC license has a one-way compat with GPLv3, meaning that a work released under GPLv3 can include CC-BY-SA 4.0 material but not the other way around. However, it doesn’t say anything about previous GPLs.
#29455 posted by Baker on 2017/07/31 03:18:59
No one reads license agreements.
Pick one that works with your situation. Then find something productive to do.
Quoth has hipnotic scorpions, many popular Quake maps have textures from non-Quake games, Arcane Dimensions got booted from Moddb for having monsters from a different game. Possibly the best secret map ever in a single player releaes has Legend of Zelda music in it.
License agreements are paperwork issues; something for a readme. No one reads them.
Baker
#29456 posted by Mugwump on 2017/07/31 06:07:52
I guess you're right about no-one reading license agreements. The thing is, in due time I intend to release this work commercially on my Bandcamp, at least on a pay-what-you-want basis. I just don't want to be cornered into a legal feud.
I suppose I could keep mum about the source of this GPL sample, I doubt anyone would recognize it anyway, considering how I modified it...
the best secret map ever in a single player releaes has Legend of Zelda music in it.
Really? What release?
The Original Rubicon.
#29457 posted by brassbite on 2017/07/31 11:48:24
Made by the master himself, John Fitzgibbons.
OK Thanks
#29458 posted by Mugwump on 2017/07/31 13:33:54
I haven't played Rubicon yet... *runs hiding in shame*
That's No Shame
#29459 posted by madfox on 2017/07/31 14:13:41
"Crossing the Rubicon" == meaningful acts that can not be overcome or impossible to come back to.
Heh!
#29460 posted by Mugwump on 2017/07/31 16:16:09
Rubicon's been on my to-play list for a loooong time, I really should get to it sometime... But there's so many great maps to play!
THICC MAPS
#29461 posted by quakeulf on 2017/08/02 18:23:42
What's the thiccest map made so far?
Thicc Is Not A Word
#29462 posted by Mugwump on 2017/08/02 18:42:02
If you mean hugest map, it's hard to tell precisely. Depends if you count size alone or factor gameplay density in. OTOH, Foggy Bogbottom, Leptis Magna & Forgotten Sepulcher from AD fit the bill, as well as Something Wicked This Way Comes or Telefragged from RRP. There's also a version of the original Quake maps all stitched together into one single gigantic map.
WARPSPASM TOO.
#29463 posted by Shambler on 2017/08/02 21:56:45
Hugest amount of rectal rekkage and all.
Warpspasm Is Still On My To-play List
#29464 posted by Mugwump on 2017/08/02 22:10:56
Thx for the reminder.
Youtube Or Twitch Channels
I made a new account just for my Quake 'tubes and would like to connect with and link to as many Quake related streamers and YTers as possible. Please reply with some names if you know of any. Either mapping or let's players. Fine by me. Please stick with Q1 subject tho.
I already know of Quake Grave and Custom Gamer. Looking for others. Thanks!
My new channel -- will mostly be hype vids like the Jam9 vid and mapping tuts for TB2.
Quaker
#29466 posted by mjb on 2017/08/02 23:10:03
MechaKnight slow plays through most released jams/releases now:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChYLm8U_Tb-nDiz2t295f4A/featured
Technically I upload playthroughs of my maps, but I am considering having commentary over the just released jam 9.
+1 Commentary
#29467 posted by Mugwump on 2017/08/02 23:16:09
MechaKnight is you?
@dumptruck The tuts will come in handy.
Nope
#29468 posted by mjb on 2017/08/03 00:01:52
MechaKnight is just a player who records his plays.
I haven't put commentary on any Quake videos yet.
Found Khreathor's YT Channel
and Rob Martem's who is always fun to listen to.
ANd BTW I like Twitch but prefer YT as Twitch BLOWS Chromecasting to TVs.
How Crap
Paper-Shub Is über Cool Tho
#29471 posted by Mugwump on 2017/08/03 00:58:42
I guess it levels the score.
MechaKnight Is Alex Hope
#29472 posted by PuLSaR on 2017/08/03 01:24:55
he renamed his channel recently I think.
T H I C C
#29473 posted by quakeulf on 2017/08/03 09:26:38
Thank you for the recommendations, I will check them out.
Also for Quake 2 I think spog's map could perhaps be called a thicc map. ;3c
Quaceulf
#29474 posted by Mugwump on 2017/08/03 10:50:52
I just saw you released a Q2 unit a few months bacc. I haven't played Q2 in years but if I reinstall it someday I'll mace sure to checc it out. Screenshots looc nice. Don't cnow if you're aware of this because you haven't posted in that thread but a news post was made about it on Func_ here. In case you wanna read the feedbacc.
Funk_msgboard
#29475 posted by quakeulf on 2017/08/03 11:04:41
Yes, I have looked at it already. I was surprised at the feedbakk given that it was my first "real" offering for Quake 2 (previously I had only released one kaizo-themed map which people hated because of the absurdly difficult opening). I hope my next SP-unit will be even better. :3
|