Necros already built QuakeSouls.

Should have known :) 

Socks mod will satiate all these needs 

Until it ships, it can do anything! 

what

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Z0vInGCjbE 

End of debate. Go charm him, czg. 

 

That looks rad as fuck necros 

http://i.imgur.com/ZdVeE4F.png 

Given the obviousness of most Quake melee attacks. Could be fun trying to parry fiend jumps... 

<@negke> that might well be the last time czg smiled 

I Work Alone Kid ... cuts me deep man :(

Just for the record, my AD mod has no melee system, no parry or DS style mechanics. I have thought about DS mechanics in Quake several times and even made a small bonfire test mod, but telling players they have to reset a level when they die, can't save anywhere they want and have to melee monsters will be tricky to get right. 

...we need a top mapper and a top modder/mapper to join forces to do it :) 

Melee in first person sucks unless it's stealth. 

Melee in first person sucks unless it's stealth.

I quite liked Dark Messiah of Might and Magic. 

shadow warrior remake had great melee mechanics 

i'd do the mod, but not interested in doing the maps :P 

Melee in first person sucks unless it's stealth.

I quite liked Dark Messiah of Might and Magic. And Skyrim. And Left4Dead/2. And the melee in Dishonoured was fine. And Riddick. 

Do the mod. Pretty sure socks mod will be open source too so there will be lots of new assets soon.
I'm sure the community will make a bunch of maps 

I think the (yet unreleased) Lunaraxe mod has much of what you describe? 

 

Secret projects!? 

The secret FifthElephant map project :p 

Are hardly secret. Abandoned yes but never secret. 

No secret melee project in the works. Move along. 

Airfist?

Slowing Quake down and making it more duel based, like in DS, won't work.

Limiting the save points would, but changes a core mechanic, possibly too much. Personally I consider quicksave broken - like a dev cheat that got left in by mistake.

Random idea for making a Quake Bonfire system:

1. Collect frags from monsters (souls)
2. Costs 10 frags to make an Altar (bonfire), wherever you like
3. Health ticks down to 10 by 1 point for each second away from a Altar
4. frags and health are saved across levels, as are Altar positions
5. Frags are dropped if not returned to an Altar

For the monsters, I think you'd need a respawn system, and a battery of additional abilities for each one, some of which are activated each time the level loads.

Yes, Binding of Isaac Champions, basically.

For level content, maybe just add moire level teleports to each map of one of the original episodes... at least to test the idea out. Complete all maps to access the rune map and complete the episode type of thing.