I need to keep this thread at the top of the forum!
Someone please make this a permanent thread! 

org not origin 

help guys:
I'm trying a Q1 total conversion(a true one! as Carmack stated in gpl readme) and I created my monsters totally re-skinning the standard knight model in qme.
So,in a supposed commercial release, may I use them also with the knight animations left untouched in qme ?
-my monsters don't resemble id original in any way and after all animations frames are only numeric values in qme not copyrighted assets I guess- 

Lets you sell the stuff too. 

Engine and game code are GPL, the content is not. Even with a new skin, it's still the original model. You'd have to create a new one from scratch. 

..qc code:
qc code is free to use and from what I saw animation frames are also listed in it so what ? 

When you say "skin" do you mean the texture or the model? At some point the word "skin" transitioned from originally meaning just texture to meaning the whole thing - texture AND model.

If your model is a completely new model built from scratch then I imagine it's fine in a commercial release. 

'may I use them also with the knight animations left untouched in qme'
if you started with the knight model in qme, then the result is still a derivative work in some small way, and still subject to id's copyright.
strictly speaking such derivative works (note that this includes maps that just contain id's textures) should not be distributed at all, but we usually do so anyway on the understanding that the recipient has the full version of quake. I believe we follow that interpretation thanks to someone at id saying it'd be okay despite not being stated in the license, but I can't prove that sadly.
you may also be able to get by on fair-use laws, depending on legal jurisdictions... so you can probably get away with loading up the model and deleting the skins+verticies+triangles. names and sizes of frames+skins is probably okay under fair use, but sticking to those frame numbers means that your resulting model is probably going to play back at the wrong speed or something stupid/ugly like that, so its not something that's really worth much anyway.

the sources for the maps was also released (under the gpl) a while back, but combining that with the vanilla textures is arguably a violation of the gpl!

if you want a _total_ conversion, then delete pak0.pak and pak1.pak from your harddrive...
(and use a different palette... if only because quake's sucks...) 

I wonder what is minimum PAK content to run engine?
I guess palette, sprites to run MENU, start map, what else? 

gfx.wad

Should be it I think. 

dp+fte will both start up with absolutely nothing, depending on your definition of 'start'.

FTE:
for instance, if fte can't find id1/pak0.pak (or equivalent) then it'll not know what sort of game its meant to be running nor which gamedirs it should use. you can get it to behave with -basedir . -quake -nohome and it'll get the idea then. alternatively put fteqw.exe+default.fmf in the same dir and you can get the same effect without commandline args (possibly with other gamedirs instead, no id1).
if there's no [qw]progs.dat then fte will fail to spawn any entities. however, it will still load the world, the PutClientInServer function will fall back to spawning the player with noclip, and the various other missing functions will be ignored. The result is that you can at least view maps with nothing but the engine and a bsp... (and one of those 3 ways to get the filesystem code to be happy).

DP:
dp tends to have extra dll dependancies. I don't know if it'll cope without a progs.dat, but it should be fine if you give it a progs with just entity self;.float movetype;void()PutClientInServer={self.movetype=8;};
or you can just compile some gpled progs. obviously this isn't needed if you're just running it as a client.

QuakeSpasm/Other:
ignoring dll dependancies, other engines will definitely need some gfx.wad, for the palette lump, the colourmap(in sw renderers) lump, conchars lump, the various sbar image lumps (apparently quakespasm doesn't need those any more). They'll also need a gfx/conback.lmp, in most cases a gfx/pop.lmp (so they actually allow loading files without the demo's pak0.pak - this file can be generated correctly from the engine source which defeats the point of the check for it). annoyingly they'll also need a player.mdl (player baselines expect it, use a renamed spr or bsp if you want). any menus that are displayed (most noticeably the main menu) will need their images to load in order to avoid sys_errors.
you'll need a progs.dat if you're running it as a server. You'll need to provide everything up to end_sys_fields without reordering etc. this will also include a few functions which will need bodies, though they can be empty (you'll probably want at least the noclip thing though).
you'll also need a map, presumably.
those are the files/lumps that I can think of. 

..to run Quake, so better leave them there.
As for my TotalConversion project, do ya think a single person could bear all the load of work needed ?
I'm relatively good at creating textures, levels, models.. even weapons(aarrrgh!), but I fall short on fx sounds and AI code for example :(
AI is an intangible thing so how could people be aware if I use IDsoftware one ? 

I found this thread about minimum code in QuakeC too: http://quakeone.com/forums/quake-talk/quake-central/11506-quakec-developer-tools.html

...but I think writing everything from scratch is kinda tedious task. 

Quake's AI uses a set of think functions for various behaviours: th_run, th_stand, th_die,etc.

These functions start a chain of frame functions: void run1 [0] () { ai_run (<somedistance>)}, void run2, run3 etc.

Each function in the chain references a frame number in []'s.

The ai_run, ai_walk, ai_slide, etc. within each chain function moves the enemy by the set distance so that the monster can move realistically with its steps. For instance, at a frame where a foot touches the floor, you might not have an ai_run function or the ai_run will have a small value so the monster stops or slows with its steps.

Other functions do other actions timed with that frame in the animation.

Study the qc source for reference. 

Is there a documentation for the QuakeC opcodes? I'm planning to write a small compiler for something less crappy than QuakeC. 

pr_comp.h in the Quake engine source code 

I have a couple of Quake related utilities that were made for Win95 era. They won't run in compatibility mode in Windows 7. I know I have the source for at least one of them. They are very unique programs I was going to hand off to Quaddicted as they don't have them in the archives. One is a fractal terrain generator (FraQuake) and the other is a map editor that creates maps from simple text files (Phase II).

So the question is:

Is there a way to have these simply recompiled to work on modern OSes? Does something "automagic" like this exist? Or are their services that I could use to port these to run on modern OSes? I obviously know next to nothing about coding. I've never run a virtual machine either. I would assume there's a way to scratch the itch but love to hear options. VBRUN300.dll is required for both of them So I assume written in Visual Basic... errr maybe? 

Generally speaking I find virtualization is the best way to keep using those tools. I use a win95 VM on my win10 machine for things like that (specifically, I set it up to run the QME installer).

Converting an app to run on modern windows otherwise would provably be a LOT of effort by comparison, unless perhaps the source code was already readily available... 

Thanks, I am looking into installing Windows 7 32bit as I have a disk and license for that (note that it has 16 bit support whereas 64 bit versions don't). I have WinXP somewhere as well but lost my license. I know there are other options but I try to not "borrow" licences. ;)

I do have the source code for one of the the two proggies but in researching this it looks like VB3 is *really* freaking old and tough to find info on this stuff when you don't know what you are doing. 

In your quaddicted upload. (Always and forever :) ) 

Of course! I thought I had to email the files to Spirit. I can upload them? Will be happy to. 

http://gamers.org/pub/idgames2/utils/level_edit/editors/fraquake.zip

Has the source in the zip. 

Ya you have to email them to spirit, but I mean please package them in the same zip beforehand and sounds cool. FraQuake? Whoa. Text mapping...hmmmm 

PhaseII is an oddity to be sure but both of these apps have a really interesting UI and are (to me) a pretty interesting part of our collective Quake lore. They were coded by a women who was injured in a car accident and kind of fell out of the Quake scene as a result. I've never been able to track down what happened to her after her hospitalization. I will email these to Spirit but here they are for the curious. No source for PhaseII unfortunately. Well worth a look IMO. That's why I wanted to get them running again.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/plh6rsopnx3c863/fraquake.zip?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/4hgvr5ojab38xnl/phase2.zip?dl=0 

Can someone point me to code that parses BSP files?

Extra beer if it's in python or the like :-)