ok, so I just discovered that the torch model 'flame.mdl' uses frame groups and my code works. 

Currently there isn't much to show, but here it is for anyone interested:
http://pecope.co/experiments/quake_web_tools/QuakeWebTools.html

You can drag various Quake file types onto the drop zone at the top and get some kind of file preview, although currently the previews are very limited.
PAK: full file list and allows you to extract the files by clicking on the filename.
WAD: displays all textures in the wad
LMP: displays the image
BSP: displays the texture lump only. Basically the same as wad
MDL: displays skins only
PAL: displays the palette (treats it as a special case LMP)
SPR: does nothing currently, though there is some stub code, so you don't get an error.

My current plan is to make all of the main file types properly preview-able in a modern web browser on any platform said browser runs. This means that it should work fine in Chrome on MacOSX, Windows and Linux. Firefox worked last time I checked, and Opera should too. No idea about Safari and IE, but supporting different browsers is not a priority as long as it works on the good ones: Firefox and Chrome.

Once previewing files works properly (and perhaps before BSP preview works... I dunno) I'd like to start making a sort of browser based TexMex, although this is something that would likely be a lot of work - even if it only supports Quake 1 format WAD. Eventually editing other formats would be nice, but it's so much work to do things like an editor, and who knows, maybe someone will port TrenchBroom to asm.js :)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asm.js

I wonder how WebQuake was made... 

The MDL format is SO much fun ... that's probably the most bizarre code I've ever written in relation to Quake. At every turn, there's something weird happening. And that's just reading. I never got around to writing it.

There were moments that felt like staring into the abyss... 

This map didn't load any textures:
http://mobile.sheridanc.on.ca/~jonescor/temp/dyn_qep1.bsp 

https://github.com/necros0/ne_modelEditor/blob/master/src/ModelFormat/QuakeMDL/MDL.java
See line 533.

Also, that code is not very good. 

Thanks for clearing that up. I knew that the arrays were a sort of hack but wasn't sure what the limitations were with them. Still, better than nothing!

Trying to compile such a statement is also an error in C (lhs is a const pointer, and thus assigning to it is a syntax error).
Yeah, the example had the array size declared because fteqcc wouldn't accept entity[]! That should have clued me in! 

necros

I don't doubt that it's possible, I just said I never got around to attempting to write it. :)

I had grand plans at one point to expand ToeTag into an entire Quake editing suite ... it was going to be amazing. And then one day I looked up from the keyboard and saw the mountain of code still ahead of me that needed writing and something broke inside of me.

Still ... it was going to be great. 

i know what you mean.
I still want to make a model editor that'll let you do modern uv mapping like you can do in 3ds max or maya but both the crap code i wrote so far and the huge amount still left to be written puts me off, just not enough time. :( 

Well, I'm not planning on doing any MDL writing for the moment, although I might look into making a tool to update the skin lumps, since that's easy. Aside from the UV format being horrible, the vertices are packed into chars, so making a tool that allows you to alter a model with minimal loss of precision seems like it wouldn't be much fun.

As I mentioned, the only thing I'm thinking about seriously for now is a viewer and WAD file editor. Oh, and probably something that allows you to create and edit PAK files, since my current code merely allows you to extract the files from inside. At least PAK is a sane format... thank god JC never implemented compression :)

A MAP editor would be fucking awesome, but that's by far the most complicated thing, so I doubt I'll ever get that far. A port of Trenchbroom using asm.js might be feasible though, but it would require also porting wxWidgets, which I could barely even get to compile normally, let alone with asm.js.

Btw, for anyone who thinks web apps are shit (yeah, most of them are I guess), the tech does seem to have gotten a LOT better in the last couple of years thanks to HTML5 and an explosion of libraries to iron over browser incompatibilities and lack of support for various standard features. There's an entire modelling package here: http://clara.io/ Compared to that I guess a basic Quake editor would be quite easy. 

I'll look into it. Currently there is basically no error checking, and only bsp 29 is supported, so there are bound to be lots of places where shit goes wrong :) 

I examined the texture info lump that I had extracted and found that entry at index 176 was garbage. No idea what caused this; The textures before and after are all fine, so it doesn't seem to be some kind of problem with my reader, but I'll have another look. I can probably get past the error if I just ignore entries with an empty name, so I'll try that for now.

Can texmex open the file? How many textures does it contain? I get 263.

My tools don't care about limits, so maybe there is a problem with this going over the 256 texture standard limit causing an error I haven't handled? Then again, the textures are simply read from the offsets defined in the file, and 176 seems to be the only one that has read as garbage.

Any help you can offer on this would be appreciated. 

I fixed the bug by ignoring entries with no name. This is the data I extracted from the file regarding the garbage entry:

compression: 0
dsize: 21656952111104
name: ""
offset: 5770699
size: 21656952111104
type: 68

Clearly the size and filename are wrong. The offset seems OK, and the type and compression are both the same as the other entries in the file, so it looks like it's just a corrupted entry. 

If anyone has any experience loading models in three.js, please let me know. I am having a lot of trouble formatting MDL data in the format required by three.js because the documentation is very poor. Thank god for Chrome's awesome debugger. 

https://github.com/fzwoch/mdl2js

https://github.com/fzwoch/bsp2js

https://github.com/michaelhoward/Quake-PAK-viewer 

I didn't even bother to search because I just assumed nobody would have bothered. Anyway, that should make things easier :) 

they are c programs. Kinda defeats the point :/

Source might have some insights though. Thanks! 

Seems he already did all of it. It's also pretty fast. Weird thing is that it only lets me play the sounds even though the messages in the log show that it's also parsing the other files.

Now I feel I've just totally been wasting my time and that I should kill myself. 

Do you know if there is a version online somewhere that can preview the other types (I can only get it to preview sounds if I run it locally - even with a webserver behind it) 

I looked at the code and he's just parsing the BSPS but not showing them in a viewer. Also, it's from two years ago, so I guess he got bored. Still pretty neat though, and I can steal his wav preview code for my own nefarious ends >:D

Thanks for the links, and sorry to spam the thread with another thanalogue. 

Well, after basically an entire day spent trying to get MDLs to render using three.js, I have finally got... non-textured pink and white MDL reviews. The texture is previewed below the window.

I will get this working one day, but probably not today. I'm so fucking pissed off with three.js's BufferGeometry class and lack of good documentation that I am going to give it a break for a day or two and perhaps work on .spr instead.

I also fixed that bug that Necros found.

http://pecope.co/experiments/quake_web_tools/QuakeWebTools.html 

i see 261 textures in texmex O_O 

I just checked and I get 261 too. With the broken texture it's 262, so I guess texmex ignores it also. Not sure why it's there or how it got there. 

now working properly after I rewrote all the code to create three.js compatible data:
http://pecope.co/experiments/quake_web_tools/QuakeWebTools.html

Maybe I'll do spr then bsp viewing next. Need to start adding more controls for the viewers too. 

the MDL viewer:
- needs view controls, yes
- should play anims at 10fps, they're all too fast now
- should allow me to select anims based on frame name and play them individually, or skip to an individual frame
- could easily support skin selection too
- would replace moldy old QME23 as my model previewer if you did this 

Thanks for the tips. I plan to do all of those things, but haven't yet, since I was just concentrating on making things work. Definitely want to do all that though, along with the option to display with or without vertex blending (with only at the moment, but trivial to disable) and it might be nice to display some kind of reference model for scale (a 128x128x128 3d box or something...)

I might also add skin lump editing, since that should be easy enough to do, but it will be something for later.

Will also be nice to allow you to preview models and other files that are inside pak files.